Catalyst Gaming
Backup Sections => Character Ban/PK Appeals => Applications and appeals => 
Half-Life 2 Roleplay => Archive => HL2RP Development[ARCHIVE] => Denied PK Appeals => Topic started by: [LL] Cpl.Panasiuk on March 11, 2012, 03:46:23 PM
-
Name: [LL] Cpl. Panasiuk
RP Name (at time of ban):C45.CCA.GRID.04.518X
STEAM ID:STEAM_0:1:20330008
Reason:Bad RP
Length:Forever
Server:City
Banner:Skopa(mainly) and KillMePlz
Why should you be unbanned?:Well I understand that my RP isn't great but I feel that if I get a second chance I could try to shape it up as much as possible.
Possible evidence of misunderstanding:Many people say that Skopa has very high standards, 2 OfCs said said it, and skopa admitted that they do in fact have high standards for RP. Also when I asked skopa why I was being PKed, he said "Many reasons" so I asked what is a recent reason, He said that I was constantly asking for promotions, Yes i did ask for a promotion, but only ONCE and plus it was intended to be a joke, as i was missing on requirement for getting promoted.
-
+SUPPORT Whenever I saw this unit RP, I always felt satisfied with what and how he was doing. He might have fucked up, but I believe what he says is true and if you give him a second chance he'll streighten right out.
-
Moved.
FIRST OF ALL: You weren't permabanned, your CHARACTER was PKed. Perma Killed.
The reason was because you had a blackmark, and I added another, not only for being a bad RPer, but you begging for promotions OOCly. And anyways, I don't have VERY high RP standards, it's just that I felt your RP wasn't fit for the CCA. Not only that, but your grammar was a bit bad. I had given you MULTIPLE warnings, and you had previously obtained two blackmarks, and one of them was removed. So, I PKed you because you get OWR'd / deserviced when you get two BMs. I may give you another chance if you prove to be a better RPer and improve on your grammar. And one thing to remember is that RP isn't about promotions, try getting them out of your mind and focus on RP, because you asked for a lot of promotions which is a BM.
But yeah, I'm open to talk about it.
-
Moved.
The reason was because you had a blackmark, and I added another, not only for being a bad RPer, but you begging for promotions OOCly. And anyways, I don't have VERY high RP standards, it's just that I felt your RP wasn't fit for the CCA. Not only that, but your grammar was a bit bad. I had given you MULTIPLE warnings, and you had previously obtained two blackmarks, and one of them was removed. So, I PKed you because you get OWR'd / deserviced when you get two BMs. I may give you another chance if you prove to be a better RPer and improve on your grammar. And one thing to remember is that RP isn't about promotions, try getting them out of your mind and focus on RP, because you asked for a lot of promotions which is a BM.
But yeah, I'm open to talk about it.
Well I never got 2 bms as far I remember it, if your are talking about 205XX, then those black marks he had were IC not OOC.
-
Ah, anyways, you already had one, so I put the extra and PKed you. You had actually already lost another unit before. And even if BMs ARE OOC, they can still be acted on.
-
I -support this appeal, you had 2 BM's, and your grammar wasn't too great. Your grammar should be great to even get in the CCA in the first place. Two black marks leads to an OWR anyway, so I definitely think this PK is fine.
-
I thought it was three blackmarks that resulted in OWR? It's changed now????
-
I thought it was three blackmarks that resulted in OWR? It's changed now????
Yeah, it changed a while back. Anyways, try not to post in PK appeals without sayin' anything usefull :p
-
This receives -support from me as well, I'm sorry for putting it this way but the standards shown were simply not good enough to roleplay as a unit, improvements can be made and you can always reapply for another unit if your grammar improves as well as your roleplay. Besides, the OWR was certainly justified and well-deserved seeing as how your character had two blackmarks.
-
Yes I understand that my grammar was pretty bad. Yes my RP wasn't great but if you give me a second chance I can improve.
-
Yes I understand that my grammar was pretty bad. Yes my RP wasn't great but if you give me a second chance I can improve.
You have already been given a second chance. The unit 205 was your first, and this was your second. Before that I actually warned you several times.
-
I don't want to sound bitchy.. but I would like to be informed of when a unit of mine is PKed.. I cant keep a count when they are getting killed left and right. Thanks.
-
Yes I understand that my grammar was pretty bad. Yes my RP wasn't great but if you give me a second chance I can improve.
You have already been given a second chance. The unit 205 was your first, and this was your second. Before that I actually warned you several times.
205 died for IC reasons, I never got a complaint about my RP with 205, Also when I got 518 No one told me that he was my "second chance" or anything
-
Yes I understand that my grammar was pretty bad. Yes my RP wasn't great but if you give me a second chance I can improve.
You have already been given a second chance. The unit 205 was your first, and this was your second. Before that I actually warned you several times.
205 died for IC reasons, I never got a complaint about my RP with 205, Also when I got 518 No one told me that he was my "second chance" or anything
Either way, you got two Black Marks on 518, meaning an OWR.
-
Yes I understand that my grammar was pretty bad. Yes my RP wasn't great but if you give me a second chance I can improve.
You have already been given a second chance. The unit 205 was your first, and this was your second. Before that I actually warned you several times.
205 died for IC reasons, I never got a complaint about my RP with 205, Also when I got 518 No one told me that he was my "second chance" or anything
Either way, you got two Black Marks on 518, meaning an OWR.
I never got black marked a second time on 518 I got OWRed because of the UED evaluations, which was for bad rp and stuff like that. Thats why I'm asking for a second chance, to improve my RP
-
I'm a bit involved as I've seen this unit through my Recruit lately. To be honest, what occurs IC should be enough. After one blackmark you should not only ICly shapen up but look at how you can improve OOCly. You lost a unit before so you should understand that the CCA is meant for strong, well played roleplay.
I'm sorry to say this, but this would occur realisticaly if the Combine were to be there under such tight protocols and if not, more often.
I think it's perfectly legit and would suggest the unpk to not happen. Plus, you can always make a new character better and more interesting then the other.
Plus, it wasn't a blacklist, just a PK. (:
-
Agreed. It's been denied, sorry.