Like so many people i think mugging is not canon and just completely fails. But some agree with it. So in the intrest of fairness, here is a vote. You decided if its allowed or not.

(If you want to see the original topic http://www.catalyst-gaming.net/index.php?topic=4602.0 )

Ok guys. I am seriously confused when it comes to the rebellion. I know we can all RP being a rebel (properly not being a lolrebel who punchhores and gets 12 points in 2 minutes) but is there an actually resistance.

Basics are if there isn't an actual group why cant there be one. An actual rebellion but you have to be selected by the other rebels. You have to be a very very good roleplayer and be able to be a rebel, staying low, plotting but not really taking on the combine, helping citizens when they are being unjustly punished etc. It could be a proper class, they get access to the black market and the leader gets access to the weapons. They keep underground, under the radar, they can have special clothing that they can switch between. On other servers its just a suitcase that they use and change clothes. On the new map they can have a permanent base, in there they have stores for the supplies and keep their contraband away for when they go above ground.
It would make being resistance more realistic and make it so there is a proper resistance, not just people claiming to be resisting the CCA and having lolrebel going "ya i rebel, i kill all combine *punchhore, runs off in S6"

So anyway, this is just a basic idea, there may even be a resistance anyway but i never see them. So anyway, please leave comments. This is both a question and comment so i didn't put it in a child board.